Dear Serial Readers,
And we come to the end! Lucilla and Oscar have been
reunited, Nugent has been banished (as well as frozen), and Mme P has declared
her charge a happy woman.
When I began this post, I felt compelled to tie up all the
questions we’ve raised into similarly neat bows, but I don’t think even Doctor
Grosse would be capable of such a comprehensive job. Instead, I’ll raise a few
more ongoing questions/notes, and invite everyone who has read along to share
how their early question have been inflected by the novel’s final chapters.
I found myself most drawn to the novel’s ongoing engagement
with Lucilla as the finder and provider of evidence. These chapters often refer
back to her earlier “experiment” with Oscar and Nugent, in which she employed
her “own way” to tell the difference between the twins. On the one hand (pun
intended), we have the Doctor insisting that her time of getting
“thrill-tingles” is long past, because she has seen and has thus lost the
“superfine-feelings” available only to the blind. At the same, she proves him
wrong only one chapter later! There she is, feeling Oscar’s face and recognizing
him as not-Nugent. This isn’t to suggest that the novel supports Lucilla’s
assertion of her powers, because it stages a complex debate about whether she
can “see” with her hands, but rather that it also doesn’t support the Doctor.
Lucilla is still her own evidence gatherer.
We might also think about Mme P’s analysis of Lucilla’s
degenerating vision through her degenerating handwriting. In this case, Lucilla
is once again not the evidence-gatherer, but the provider of evidence for other
characters who want to diagnose her changing condition. How do these moments of
analysis fit into what Susan identified as The Tyranny of Oversight? Not only
does Mme P read the change in handwriting as the legible sign of illegible
impairment, but she also reads Lucilla’s new handwriting as a shift in
identity. This new writer is “a stranger,” regardless of her consistent tone,
because the form of her characters has changed. How does Mme P map the mutation
in written form onto the form of Lucilla’s body? To what extent does the novel
corroborate or complicate that mapping?
Finally, I wonder at the ways that the novel ends in an
attempted placement of blame. Doctor Grosse insists that his eye surgery has
not failed in recreating her sight. Instead, he tells Lucilla, “it is you who
have failed to take care of your nice new eyes when I gave them to you.” Even
if Lucilla doesn’t see her regained blindness as a failure, and if other
doctors disagree with Grosse’s opinion, the novel gives him the space to blame
Lucilla for her own disablement. Grosse neatly embodies the medical model of
disability (as an individual problem which requires a cure to regain individual
wholeness) while it was still being created, but is he represented as correct?
Are Lucilla and her caregivers portrayed as having ruined her opportunity for
vision or are the attempts to shelter her eyes and mind portrayed as ill
founded from the start?
Thanks to everyone for reading along, and I look forward to
your thoughts on the end of our odd little adventure!
Serially Satisfied,
